"Moonmaid" by Teri Santitoro!
2nd Place was "Being in the Dark" by Zhanna P Rader.
3rd Place was a 4-way tie between:
"First in the Morn" by Gary Blankenship
"Samhain Sabbat" by jborneman
"Note on the kitchen counter" by Rich Magahiz
"almost touching" by s.c.virtes
My personal favorite poem was "Sight" by jenni_moody but it unfortunately had the wrong syllable count.